Capitalism versus Communism: Half-time

Outside Fortress Europe Excerpts
This brief essay is based upon excerpts from Chapter One, Ten Years That Shook the (Capitalist) World: 1988-1998, in Outside Fortress Europe: Strategies for the Global Market, published in 2018 by Strategic Management Think Tank.


Outside Fortress Europe Excerpt

What we know is a drop; what we don’t know is an ocean.
Sir Isaac Newton (1643-1727).
Mathematician, astronomer, theologian, author and physicist.

Students of history will recognise that the title of this Chapter is derivative. It is ‘borrowed’ from a classic example of reportage, John Reed’s immersive account of the 1917 Russian Revolution Ten Days That Shook the World (Reed, 2007). Originally published in 1919, here is the description of the work from the editor of the Penguin Classic reprint:

A contemporary journalist writing in the first flush of revolutionary enthusiasm, [Reed] gives a gripping record of the events in Petrograd in November 1917, when Lenin and the Bolsheviks finally seized power. Containing verbatim reports both of speeches by leaders and the chance comments of bystanders, set against an idealized backcloth of the proletariat, soldiers, sailors, and peasants uniting to throw off oppression. Reed’s account is the product of passionate involvement and remains an unsurpassed classic of reporting.

Reed’s passion was for the Bolshevik cause and socialism more generally and he was unashamedly honest in stating this in the book’s introduction. But Reed’s admiration was for the cerebral Lenin and it was ultimately the brutal thug Stalin who sowed the seeds of failure of the Soviet dream, so presciently observed by George Orwell in Animal Farm, published at a time when criticising ‘Uncle Joe’ was unfashionable, to say the least, especially in America. The most memorable (and frequently quoted) line from Orwell’s 1945 allegorical novella is “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others” (Orwell, 2000). The inequality alluded to in this sentence has been widely interpreted as a cause for the demise of communism, but this is fundamentally flawed for two key reasons:

    1. It assumes that communism has failed which, as we have demonstrated in this book, as a political system it continues to thrive in a nation of 1,415,000,000 souls in China; add to this 93,000,000 in Vietnam, 25,000,000 in North Korea, 12,000,000 in Cuba and more.
    2. It assumes that capitalism delivers equality in wealth which, as French economist Thomas Piketty (2014) has demonstrated in his extremely thought-provoking and successful book, Capital in the Twenty-First Century, this is patently not the case, the only surprise being that, in contrast to what Marx had predicted, the huge inequalities in wealth which capitalism has created hasn’t attracted any significant, sustained, ‘beyond state’ rebellious reaction. From this perspective, the capitalist nation-state has survived and prospered. What has triumphed is market economics and it is this which provides the context for much of what features in Outside Fortress Europe: Strategies for the Global Market.

Furthermore, as The Economist noted in a special briefing on one aspect of globalization – regional inequality, primarily in wealthier, developed economies including the UK, Germany and in TrumpLand mid-west USA, there are many ‘Left-behind places’; but in the briefing they also devote attention to those economic policies which governments, both national and regional, can adopt to address the problem (Economist, 2017, October 21st). This message should be heeded but that this is not a new idea should also be acknowledged: the influential economist John Kenneth Galbraith (1999) in his most impactful book, The Affluent Society, originally published in 1958 when America was drenched in post-war prosperity, recognised that capitalism is great at creating wealth but less good at distributing it more equitably or allocating it in a more meaningful way for the benefit of wider society.

Such inequality within a country is now demonstrable in China where the bulk of its economic growth and wealth creation has arisen in the south-east, largely as a result of state enablement of market economics to flourish within the Special Economic Zones (SEZs) it created in carefully designated geographic locations (click/tap the A Tale of Two Chinas tab for details). So the answer to the question ‘Capitalism versus Communism’ focuses upon three dimensions: state, society and markets. Which raises another question which has as its focus the individual and their place in the grand schematic of political economy.

Starting with the Preface to this book (Outside Fortress Europe: Strategies for the Global Market) we have introduced and discussed the seminal, prescient work of Adam Smith and without doubt his Wealth of Nations treatise can be seen as a blueprint for capitalism (Smith, 1776). Perhaps the strongest critique made of his philosophy has related to its emphasis on the ‘self-interest’ motivation of individual actors which was at its core and which we discussed earlier in this Chapter. But, as renowned psychology professor Stephen Pinker (2018) has observed:

Smith was not saying that people are ruthlessly selfish, or that they ought to be; he was one of history’s keenest commentators on human sympathy. He only said that in a market, whatever tendency people have to care for their families and themselves can work to the good of all. Exchange can make an entire society not just richer but nicer, because in an effective market it is cheaper to buy things than to steal them, and other people are more valuable to you alive than dead.

This sounds like a reasonable post-Brexit philosophy for the relationship between the UK and the remaining members of its partner in divorce, the EU. Only time will tell and only a fool would tell you otherwise.

Outside Fortress Europe Excerpt References

Economist. (2017, October 21st). In the lurch: Many places have lost out to globalisation. What can be done to help them? The Economist, 19-24.
Galbraith, J. K. (1999). The Affluent Society: Updated with a New Introduction by the Author (5 Rev ed.). London: Penguin Business.
Orwell, G. (2000). Animal Farm: A Fairy Story. London: Penguin Classics.
Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Boston: Harvard University Press.
Pinker, S. (2018). Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism and Progress. London: Viking.
Reed, J. (2007). Ten Days That Shook the World (Penguin Classics). London: Penguin.
Smith, A. (1776). An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. Edinburgh: Strathan & Cadell.


What Happens Next?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         …or this?


Emerging markets – emerge!


India et al…
From the world’s biggest democracy to the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, the People’s Republic of Bangladesh and the Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka, approximately 1.8bn souls (who knows?) populate the Indian subcontinent. Here we find multiple variations on the theme of ‘democracy’ enmeshed within religious and militaristic influence and control systems. And also the biggest single innovation in capitalism and developmental economics in 300 years: microfinance.

Fusce pellentesque lacus et mattis porta. Integer sagittis sem ornare placerat rhoncus. Pellentesque tincidunt ipsum mi, ac fermentum diam posuere in. Cras elementum sem diam, a congue turpis rutrum at. Sed iaculis nunc ut lobortis malesuada. Sed gravida lectus massa, a eleifend magna porta at. Vestibulum pulvinar nisi ac purus ullamcorper, sed mollis elit mattis. Nunc rutrum ac ligula ut sagittis. Vivamus vitae metus ut dui consectetur fringilla in in sapien. Donec tempor, ipsum dictum commodo sollicitudin, dolor sem scelerisque dui, eu laoreet enim ante eget tortor. Nullam sed rhoncus enim, at facilisis lectus. Suspendisse malesuada mauris quam, sed finibus tellus porttitor non. Quisque eleifend ex non risus faucibus accumsan. Pellentesque quis consequat tortor, id aliquet ante. In aliquet tellus eu nulla convallis blandit.

South America
Sed ut nunc non nulla porta vestibulum. Suspendisse ut eros pulvinar, elementum mauris ac, dapibus risus. Donec euismod nisl sapien, eleifend vehicula enim porta ac. In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Praesent quis velit erat. Vestibulum pellentesque feugiat orci, in maximus risus aliquet vitae. Fusce nunc velit, mattis eu lectus dignissim, blandit malesuada enim. Sed pellentesque bibendum metus, eget mollis arcu feugiat vel. Cras placerat, felis fringilla condimentum volutpat, massa metus hendrerit lorem, vitae pretium libero nibh et massa. Morbi at nisi at velit sodales commodo vel non ligula. Donec ac maximus erat. Quisque in arcu metus. Donec congue nisi at condimentum euismod. Suspendisse rutrum posuere nisl, nec viverra massa facilisis vitae. Phasellus semper quis magna vitae imperdiet. Donec lobortis commodo faucibus.

Vivamus pulvinar tellus quis elit maximus sodales. Phasellus quis mi sit amet augue auctor vulputate. Suspendisse posuere mattis venenatis. Aenean tincidunt pellentesque vestibulum. Proin blandit placerat lorem, et finibus lectus. Integer ut justo ut nunc aliquet pharetra. Aliquam vel lorem porttitor elit euismod tristique sed eu elit. Mauris luctus risus non felis congue euismod. Morbi et lectus nec neque placerat tempus ut ut ligula. Aenean gravida justo sit amet tincidunt ultrices. Vestibulum id est id metus luctus sodales at ut urna. Nam ullamcorper condimentum consectetur.

Maecenas mattis dui ut nibh hendrerit condimentum. Quisque vehicula urna ut molestie congue. Sed luctus ultrices ante ac sollicitudin. Donec non lectus volutpat felis viverra rhoncus. Morbi efficitur diam nec diam cursus convallis. Phasellus lacus arcu, hendrerit sit amet finibus finibus, fermentum eu eros. Vestibulum eu metus ut velit tristique suscipit sed in nisi. Duis at mi ultrices, convallis sapien non, convallis mi. Quisque volutpat elementum mauris, quis consequat velit porttitor id. Suspendisse eget orci interdum, vestibulum augue vestibulum, dignissim tortor. Nulla rhoncus ligula est, non convallis nibh venenatis eget. Mauris egestas, nisi a tempor bibendum, tortor nisi lobortis erat, non fermentum mauris risus vitae enim. Sed dapibus in dui a ultrices. Donec mi ante, imperdiet nec sem eget, convallis efficitur leo. Aenean a metus elit. Aenean eu magna non mi aliquam pulvinar.


Planet Bitcoin?
Aliquam accumsan est et nisi posuere viverra. Quisque non diam a enim ornare tincidunt. Suspendisse malesuada mollis purus, pellentesque porta odio bibendum ut. Aenean varius sem pretium est rutrum, sed volutpat lorem euismod. Orci varius natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Nullam consectetur libero ut diam egestas, et feugiat ante lobortis. Nullam varius maximus ultricies. Vestibulum et dolor ornare, elementum ligula et, pulvinar turpis. Orci varius natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Curabitur pharetra enim in condimentum varius. Maecenas vestibulum egestas ante, quis luctus risus hendrerit non. Fusce euismod eros nisl, id pharetra lectus ullamcorper eget. Donec id ante lacinia, euismod arcu sit amet, condimentum sapien. In tincidunt nisi ac tortor rhoncus, ut pretium justo convallis. Nunc mi tellus, vulputate et ante et, semper interdum neque.


Please click/tap your browser ‘Back’ button to return to the location navigated from. Alternatively, click/tap the ‘Mao Portrait / Bitcoin’ graphic below to navigate to the Communomics home page.

All content © Colin Edward Egan, 2020